Buddhism
of Wisdom & Faith
7. SEEK A RESPONSE WITHIN A DEFINITE TIME FRAME
The Great Issue of Birth and Death
Only Buddhism discusses and offers a thorough
solution to the religious truth "swift is the wave of impermanence, great
is the issue of Birth and Death." Philosophers merely deal with the
questions of everyday life -- after birth and before death. They do not
thoroughly investigate the issue of Birth and Death -- before birth and after
death.
Confucius did
comment on the after-life, but he did so with the goal of fulfilling filial
obligations and conducting rites and ceremonies according to the motto
"worship the dead as if they were still alive." Once, when one of
Confucius' disciples asked him about death, he replied "You who do not
even know about life, how can you know about death?"
The Taoist solution
to the problem of death is to lengthen the lifespan, attempting to achieve
immortality.
However, while we may live longer, we cannot escape death,
because all conditioned dharmas are within the cycle of Birth and Death. In the
truth of the Twelve Links of Dependent Origination, Buddha Sakyamuni identified
the source, demonstrating clearly that "birth, old age, disease, death,
worry, love-attachment and unhappiness" are caused by a single, original
thought called delusion. To destroy delusion and return to the Original Nature
is to completely eliminate the source of Birth and Death Yet, this is only
severing attachment to self and others we should also sever
attachment to self and dharmas to attain the stage of complete
Enlightenment Nevertheless, to be free of attachment to self and others and dwell
in Nirvana without Remainder -- escaping the sufferings of the Triple Realm --
is still a very difficult step which is rarely achieved. It is also the first
stage for cultivators.
As Sakyamuni Buddha predicted, in the
Dharma-Ending Age, those who have awakened to the Way are rare
enough, not to speak of those who have attained Enlightenment. And,
if we have not attained Enlightenment, we are, by necessity, subject to Birth
and Death. Therefore, to solve the problem of Birth and Death in this very
life, in the middle of the Dharma-Ending Age, there is only one expedient,
"to take our karma along to the Western Pure Land." Why is this so?
It is because, if we have neither attained Enlightenment nor
achieved rebirth in the Pure Land, we are necessarily mired in Birth and Death.
As we revolve in the realm of the Five Turbidities, deep in the
Dharma-Ending Age, morality and virtue keep declining, bad karma is easy to
commit and good conditions are difficult to create. In the end, we cannot
escape from the three Evil Paths. Thus, Birth and Death is the big issue.
Practitioners seeking rebirth in the Pure Land should bear it in mind day in
and day out.
A famous Chinese Master of recent times, when still a young boy
at home, saw the flowers wither and die in front of his parents' house and
began to ponder and shed tears ... This monk, full of wisdom, had when still
young, deeply realized the truth of Birth and Death as the common fate of all
sentient beings!
The
Meaning of Conducting a Retreat
As
indicated above, if we have not attained Enlightenment, we should recite the
Buddha's name seeking rebirth in the Pure Land. To ensure that this occurs, we
should recite to the level of one-pointedness of mind. And, in order to
practice to that level, we should conduct periodic retreats. To be "in
retreat" is to retire to a small house, meditation hut or small
room, cut off all outside activities and conditions and concentrate on reciting
the Buddha's name for a period of seven days. Why seven days and not six or
eight?
The Amitabha Sutra states:
Sariputra:
if a good man or a good woman hears Amida Buddha preach and firmly holds the
Name wholeheartedly and singlemindedly, be it for one day, two days, three
days, four days, five days, six days, or seven days, Amida Buddha, together
with all the holy multitudes, will appear before that person as the end of life
draws near. When death arrives, that person, with mind undisturbed, at once
gains rebirth in Amida Buddha's Land of Utmost Happiness.
Since
the Sutra does not refer to six days
only, nor does it speak of eight days,
Pure Land practitioners, basing themselves on the words of Buddha Sakyamuni,
have traditionally taken the period of retreat as seven days.
According
to the Esoteric School, the number seven is the ultimate number in the cycle of
Birth and Death. Therefore, in the bardo stage, the "soul" must
undergo changes every seven days, and to be efficacious, mantras should be
recited at least seven times. Buddhist texts note this with the words "the
Dharma is thus," according to the law of nature it has to be that
way and cannot be explained, just as it is difficult to explain why fire is hot
and ice is cold. Starting with the number seven and multiplying it by three or
seven, we have twenty-one or forty-nine. Therefore, the Esoteric School teaches
that mantras should be recited at least seven times to be effective, twenty-one
or forty-nine times if the mind is weak and agitated. Thus, basing themselves
on this teaching, practitioners arrange retreat periods of seven, twenty-one or
forty-nine days.
What
does it mean to have "one-pointedness of mind"?
It
means to concentrate the mind on recitation, without sundry thoughts. "One-pointedness" means
the mind is devoid of all distractions, thinking about no other realm except the
realm of Buddha Recitation. Individuals of high capacities may reach such a
state in, perhaps, one day, those of moderate capacities in three or four days,
those of limited capacities in seven days. Looking at it from another point of
view, individuals of high capacities, ideally, achieve one-pointedness of mind
during the entire seven-day period, those of moderate capacities only do so for
three or four days, while those of limited capacities may only do so for one
day during the whole period of retreat.
However,
why did Buddha Sakyamuni estimate that we could achieve one-pointedness of mind
within a week, when in fact, some of us may recite for two or three or even
many years without ever reaching that state? This situation results from three
causes.
1.
From the viewpoint of "marks", we fail to follow Buddha Sakyamuni's
admonition to conduct periodic retreats for cultivation. When we do so, we
engage in several practices at the same time. We should realize that if we
would like to achieve one-pointedness of mind, we should practice Oral
Recitation exclusively during the retreat period, and not engage in
Mantra or Sutra Recitation or meditation as well.
2.
There are various reasons why some practitioners cannot avoid sundry conditions
and thoughts or concentrate on cultivation for seven days. These reasons range
from lack of external support (the need to prepare their own meals and
attend to other miscellaneous activities) to lack of earnestness.
3.
The three capacities mentioned above are a rough estimation. For example,
within the category of high capacity cultivators, we have "supremely
high," "moderately high," and "low high" capacities.
Moderate and limited capacities may likewise be subdivided. There are thus a total
of nine categories, which may in turn be divided into many more
categories.
We
should also realize that Buddha Sakyamuni's words are only generalities. For
example, the sutras state that individuals of high capacities can achieve
one-pointedness of mind for seven days, not eight or nine. In reality, these
sages are not only undisturbed for eight or nine days; conceivably, their minds
can remain empty and still during their entire lives. Conversely, those of
limited capacities, weighed down by heavy karmic obstructions, not only may fail
to reach one-pointedness of mind after seven days, they may even recite during
their whole lifetime without ever reaching that state.
Thus,
we should interpret the words and meaning of the sutras flexibly, without being
attached to the words and betraying the phrase, or grasping at the phrase and
doing injustice to the meaning.
How
to Conduct a Seven-Day Retreat
In
conducting a seven-day retreat, one can either practice alone, to attain purity
more easily, or with many other cultivators. In either case, three types of
good spiritual advisors are required.
1. Teaching Spiritual Advisor
2. Caretaking Spiritual Advisors
This
refers to one or several persons assisting with outside daily chores such as
preparing meals or cleaning up, so that those on retreat can cultivate
peacefully without distraction. Such persons are called "retreat
assistants."
3. Common Practice Spiritual Advisors
These
are persons who practice the same method as the individual on retreat. They
keep an eye on one another, encouraging and urging each other on. These
cultivators can either be participants in the same retreat or cultivators
living nearby. In addition to keeping an eye out and urging the practitioners
on, they can exchange ideas or experiences for the common good. This concept
has been captured in a proverb:
Rice
should be eaten with soup, Practice should be conducted with friends.
An
Elder Master of great virtue in the Zen tradition once taught:
The
practitioner should take the ten directions as his perfect Enlightenment seat,
and not set a limit to the length of retreats. If one year is not sufficient to
become enlightened, he should meditate for ten years. If ten years are not
enough, then he should meditate for twenty or thirty years, or up to his whole
lifetime, always unwavering in his determination.
Pure
Land followers should do likewise. Attending a seven-day retreat is the best
expedient to reach one-pointedness of mind. If one retreat is not sufficient,
then he should cultivate during many retreats, never wavering in his
determination.
Some
might ask, "To achieve rebirth in the Pure Land, we should recite to the
level of one-pointedness of mind. However, since few practitioners can reach
that level today, are we not wasting our efforts?"
Answer: I briefly answered that
question earlier and will repeat the answer here for emphasis. The goal of
Buddha Recitation is one-pointedness of mind or samadhi. However, the Pure Land
method has one particular characteristic, namely:
Those
"above" should reach the state of undisturbed mind; for those
"below," only ten thoughts will bring success.
In
other words, those of high capacities who recite to the level of
one-pointedness of mind in this
very life will be assured of rebirth in the Pure Land. On the other hand,
those of limited capacities who can have ten undisturbed thoughts at the time of death will
also achieve rebirth there. Therefore, the question of an "undisturbed
mind achieving rebirth in the Pure Land" applies at the time of death, not
during this current life. Moreover, even if we achieve one-pointedness of mind
in our usual practice, should we, on our deathbed, change course and practice
other methods, we will not achieve rebirth in the Pure Land.
To
have ten undisturbed thoughts at the moment of death is, in truth, no easy
thing. This is because at that time, we are faced with a karma-power, caused by
current and past transgressions, called "near death karma." If
we do not practice Buddha Recitation diligently in our daily lives, that near
death karma will overpower the mind. Right thoughts cannot then arise and the
mind-consciousness will be disturbed at the time of death. Under these
circumstances, how can we achieve rebirth in the Pure Land?
There
was once a lay Pure Land practitioner who liked to perform Buddhist works, but
his daily recitation was only perfunctory. At the time of death, he developed
an aversion to hearing the Buddha's name and refused to follow the admonitions
of fellow practitioners. Elder Master Yin Kuang concluded:
This
was due to bad karma accrued from time immemorial, in particular the karma of
stinginess in giving advice, seeing people headed toward death but not warning
them. These inauspicious signs are indications of impending rebirth among
hungry ghosts.
Buddha
Sakyamuni once said to his disciple, Ananda, "Some people perform good
deeds all their lives, but at the time of death are reborn in the hells; others
create bad karma all their lives, yet at the time of death are reborn in the
heavens. Do you know the reason why?" Ananda said, "Great Master,
please teach us the causes." The Lord Buddha said, "When those who
perform good deeds are reborn in the hells, it is because their good karma in
this life has not matured, while their bad karma from time immemorial has come
to fruition. Conversely, when those who create bad karma in this lifetime are
reborn in the heavens, it is because their bad karma in this life has not
reached maturity, while their good karma from past lives has borne fruit. Good
and bad karma interact for many lifetimes before emerging. As with
debts, the most important is repaid first. Therefore the cultivator
should be diligent in daily life, and not indifferent or lazy."
Thus,
upon reflection, we can see that the practitioner seeking rebirth in the Pure
Land should, in daily life, diligently apply himself to recitation. This will
facilitate the development of one-pointedness of mind at the time of
death. For this reason, if we do not routinely achieve pure recitation,
we should make it a point to attend many retreats.
Phenomena
and Principle
"Principle" is
truth, reason, the realm of understanding and Awakening and belongs to the
sphere of "essence."
"Phenomena" are
expedients, practices, deeds, "form," and fall under the heading of
"marks."
However,
at the ultimate level, phenomena are noumenon, essence is mark, and both belong
to the same truth-like state, all-illuminating, all-pervading. In cultivation,
noumenon and phenomena are the two sides of a coin, interacting with one
another and helping one another. With noumenon, we have a basis, a
direction, a goal to develop into action. With phenomena, we are able to
actualize what we think, demonstrate our understanding, reach our goal and,
ultimately, achieve results.
Noumenon
is like the eyes that watch the road. Phenomena are like the feet that set out
to walk. Without eyes, or with glassy, dim eyes, it is easy to get
lost. Without feet, however sharp our eyes, there is no way to reach our
destination. To "have" noumenon but not phenomena is like having a
map and knowing the way, but refusing to proceed. To "have" phenomena
but not noumenon is like setting out on a journey with neither a guide nor a
clear itinerary. To have both noumenon and phenomena is not only to know the
way perfectly but also to proceed to walk. We cannot fail to reach the City of
Lights.
Noumenon
and phenomena, essence and marks are thus interdependent. If one factor is
missing, success is illusory. However, even though the practitioner may not
have experienced Awakening, if he follows the itinerary taught by the sages and
cultivates, he, too, can reach the goal and succeed. Sutras, commentaries,
biographies, as well as the writings of ancient masters and advice from today's
good spiritual advisors -- these constitute the itinerary. If we follow these
teachings and put them into practice, we will surely achieve results.
Therefore, practice without theory is not necessarily a cause for alarm. Of
more concern are those who understand theory but fail to put it into
practice. Verbalizing incessantly, they discourse without end about
the mysterious and the wonderful, but they do not progress one step during
their entire lives.
In
truth, however, those who lack practice are not really in possession of theory
either. Why is this so? As an analogy, if a person knows his house is on fire,
yet remains inside without trying to escape, is he any different from someone
who is not aware of the fire? Therefore, the Dharma can help those who
are of limited capacity and understanding, but cannot save those who possess
mundane intelligence and eloquence but are lacking in practice.
It
once happened that a particularly dull-witted disciple of the Buddha
named Suddipanthaka was taught only two words, "broom" and "sweep," and
was asked to meditate on them. He was so stupid that when he remembered one of
the words, he would immediately forget the other. However, thanks to his power
of perseverance, never neglecting his cultivation even for a single moment, he
ultimately became an Arhat. On the other hand, although Devadatta was
more intelligent than most, fully conversant with the Dharma and possessing
the five spiritual powers, he ultimately descended to the hells because of
his greed for fame and fortune and his lack of true cultivation.
Thus,
we can see that even though we may be versed in the Tripitaka, without actual
practice, our knowledge and understanding are useless. This is because our
karmic obstacles from time immemorial are still intact, not reduced in the
slightest. How, then, can we hope to compare with an old, dull-witted kitchen
helper, her face covered with soot, who diligently practices Buddha Recitation?
One day she will reach one-pointedness of mind and be at peace, ending up
seated on a lotus blossom!
Therefore,
individuals who spend their entire lives seeking understanding based on
reasoning grounded in forms and marks -- hoping to become Buddhist scholars
while not truly cultivating -- are surely in the same position as those who can
list succulent dishes but must endure hunger pangs, or those who count other
people's money while remaining poor and destitute themselves. Buddha
Sakyamuni compared those persons to deaf musicians playing violins for the
multitude or merchants peddling all kinds of wonderful drugs while forgetting
that they themselves are afflicted with many diseases.
Those
who are determined to study the Dharma should pay heed to this point.
Buddha
Recitation -- Essence and Practice
There
are two aspects to Buddha Recitation -- essence and practice. According to
Elder Master Ou-I:
"Buddha
Recitation-practice" means believing that there is
a Western Pure Land and a Lord Buddha named Amitabha, but not yet realizing
that "this Mind makes Buddha,
this Mind is Buddha." It consists of resolutely seeking rebirth in the
Pure Land and reciting as earnestly as a lost child longing for his mother,
never forgetting her for a single moment.
"Buddha
Recitation-essence," on the other hand, means
believing and understanding that Lord Amitabha Buddha of the West inherently
exists in full within our mind, is created by our mind, and making this sacred
name -- inherently existing in full within our mind and created by our mind --
the focus of our recitation, without a moment of neglect."
In
other words, "Buddha Recitation-practice" is the
method of those who do not understand anything about meaning or essence, who
just believe that there is a Land of Ultimate Bliss and a Buddha named
Amitabha, and who fervently and earnestly recite the Buddha's name seeking
rebirth there.
"Buddha
Recitation-essence" is the method of those who
practice in an identical manner, but who also deeply realize that the Pure Land
and Lord Amitabha Buddha are all in the True Mind, manifested by the pure
virtues of the True Mind.
This
being so, is there a difference between Buddha Recitation-practice and Buddha
Recitation-essence? Of course there is. Those who follow Buddha
Recitation-practice see Amitabha Buddha as outside the Mind; therefore,
opposing marks of subject-object still exist. Thus, such practice is not yet
all-encompassing and complete. Those who practice Buddha
Recitation-essence thoroughly understand the True Mind and therefore sever all
marks of subject-object -- to recite is Buddha, to recite is Mind, reconciling
Mind and Realm.
Let
me relate an anecdote. One night, a Master who is a friend of this author
dreamed that a yellow-robed monk came to ask him, "You practice Buddha
Recitation, but what is Buddha?" Answer "Buddha
is Mind." The monk continued, "How about explaining to me what you
mean by Buddha is Mind?" In his dream, the author's friend improvised the
following stanzas:
Each
utterance of the Buddha's name following the rosary is Mind,
Buddha is clearly Mind, why waste time searching for Him?
The Buddha's sea of wisdom reconciles Mind and Realm!
Mind and Buddha are born equal.
To
abandon Mind and follow the Buddha is to be still in a dream,
To be attached to the Buddha as Mind is not yet perfect comprehension;
Mind and Buddha are both originally illusory and dreamlike,
To transcend both Buddha and Mind is to arrive at the perfect City of Lights.
The
Master understood the essence of Buddha Recitation, reconciling the Buddha's
name with the realm of the Mind.
There
is one erroneous idea, prevalent among those who lean toward the subtle and the
mysterious, which requires clarification. Many of them, emphasizing theory over
practice, tend to be attached to the concept of "Amitabha as the
Self-Nature, Pure Land as Mind-Only," and reject the existence of
the Western Pure Land or rebirth there. These individuals explain the sutra
teachings on Pure Land from the viewpoint of principle or essence, saying
"Amitabha is our Buddha Nature, the Pure Land is the pure realm of the
Mind, why seek it on the outside?" This is the great mistake of those who
emphasize mundane, conventional reasoning.
They
cling to theory while neglecting practice, prefer essence to marks, and rely on
Ultimate Truth to reject the manifestations of mundane truth -- failing to
realize that the two are inseparable.
According
to the Treatise on the Awakening of the Faith, the
True Mind has two aspects: essence and marks. The aspect of essence is called
the Door of True Thusness, the aspect of marks is the Door of Birth and Death.
True Thusness is inseparable from Birth and Death; Birth and Death are True Thusness. This is
why the Patriarch Asvaghosha called True Thusness the "truth-like
Emptiness treasury" and Birth and Death the "truth-like
Non-Emptiness treasury." True Thusness and Birth and death have
the same truth-like nature.
Take
the great ocean as an example. We cannot accept sea water but not waves. If we
were to do so, we would be wrong about the manifestations of the ocean and fail
to understand truly what the ocean is. Therefore, when we abandon phenomena,
noumenon cannot stand by itself; when we reject marks, essence cannot remain
stable.
A
great many individuals, educated in mundane ways, become afflicted with the
disease of grasping at the "Truth of Emptiness" when they study
Mahayana sutras, particularly those that expound the Prajna Paramita truth,
which they do not fully understand. Thus, they explain sutras which elucidate
phenomena and marks, such as the Pure Land Sutras or the Earth Store Bodhisattva Sutra, from
the viewpoint of noumenon and principle. They mistake these "marks"
sutras as expedients to guide those of limited capacities. However, in
truth, they are the mistaken ones! In this connection, I will quote a
few passages from the sutras, to destroy this attachment to Emptiness.
As
stated in the Heart
Sutra:
There
is no wisdom, and there is no attainment whatsoever. Because there is nothing
to be attained, a Bodhisattva relying on Prajnaparamita has no obstruction in
his mind. Because there is no obstruction he has no fear, and he passes far
beyond all confused imaginations and reaches ultimate Nirvana. The Buddhas in
the past, present and future, also, by relying on the Prajnaparamita,
"have" attained Supreme Enlightenment.
At
first, Buddha Sakyamuni, in accord with Ultimate Truth, said "there is no
attainment whatsoever." Then, in accord with conventional truth, He said
"the Buddhas in the past, present and future have attained Supreme
Enlightenment." Seeing "attainment" is attachment
to existence. Seeing "non-attainment" is to err in
the direction of attachment to emptiness. Therefore, cultivators should
thoroughly understand the deep meaning behind the sutras and enter the Middle
Way.
In
the Diamond Sutra, Sakyamuni Buddha stated:
Who
sees Me by form,
Who seeks Me in sound,
Perverted are his footsteps upon the Way;
For he cannot perceive the Tathagata.
Subhuti,
do not think the opposite either that when the Tathagata attained Supreme
Enlightenment it was not by means of his possession of the thirty-two marks of
physical excellence. Do not think that. Should you think that, then when you
begin the practice of seeking to attain supreme enlightenment you would think
that all systems of phenomena and all conceptions about phenomena are to be cut
off and rejected. Do not think that. And why? Because when a disciple
practices seeking to attain supreme enlightenment, he should neither grasp
after such arbitrary conceptions of phenomena nor reject them.
First,
Buddha Sakyamuni taught that we should not follow sounds, forms and marks in
seeking the Way. After that, he reminded us that at the same time, we should
not abandon sounds, forms and marks, nor should we destroy all dharmas. Thus,
we can see that the Way belongs neither to "forms" nor to
"emptiness." Clinging to either aspect is misguided. A
famous Zen monk once said:
Thirty
years ago, when this old monk had not yet entered the Order, he perceived
rivers as rivers and mountains as mountains. After meeting good spiritual
advisors who taught him how to cultivate, he saw rivers as not-rivers and
mountains as not-mountains. Now that he has seen the Way and reached
the state of still emptiness, he realizes that rivers have always been rivers
and mountains have always been mountains.
A
Zen poet, Su Tung P'o, expressed the same idea:
The
sound of the stream is the Buddhas' vast long tongue,
The shape of the mountain is intrinsically the pure Dharma body.
The
meaning of the poem is that forms, marks and sounds are intrinsically the Great
Way. We should understand them with a non-discriminating mind, neither clinging
to them nor rejecting them to seek Enlightenment in the realm of hollow
emptiness. Therefore, the phrase, "Self-Nature Amitabha, Mind-Only Pure
Land" is not a denial of the Pure Land or Amitabha Buddha, but is rather
an expression that gathers marks toward essence, brings "function"
toward nature, to manifest the ultimate truth of the Void. In this
ultimate truth, even Buddhas do not exist, let alone other dharmas.
The
ancients have said:
Although
theory can be understood in a flash, practice should be carried out step by
step.
Even
in Zen, which is said to be a "direct method," as long as we have to
sit in meditation, or gather our mind, or meditate on a koan or enter and exit
samadhi, we are still within the sphere of expedients. Moreover, in the
metaphysical realm, there are many levels of attainment. Not until we have
reached the stage of non-cultivation can we dispense with expedients and really
proclaim that all dharmas are empty. If we
have not reached that stage, even a small thing
like a mote of dust is real; we still feel warm near a fire or cold in the
midst of frost and we still feel pain when a small thorn pricks our body --
how, then, can we say that all dharmas are non-existent and void?
Therefore,
those who like to advance lofty and wonderful propositions, such as "Amitabha
is the Self-Nature, the Pure Land is Mind Only," and go on to reject the
actual practice of Buddha Recitation will find themselves in the predicament of
"destroying the boat before stepping ashore." There is no way such
persons can avoid drowning. On the contrary, since ancient times, those who
have thoroughly understood essence have always paid particular attention to
practice -- because practice symbolizes essence.
The
ancients have said:
Only
those endowed with wisdom can reconcile the essence and marks of Buddha
Recitation and truly understand it in an exhaustive manner. Otherwise, we had
better grasp at marks in our cultivation; the more we do so, the more effective
our practice will be.
This
is because the more we cling to forms, the more earnest is our determination to
achieve rebirth in the Pure Land. Once reborn there, we will surely be awakened
to the True Mark. The subject of phenomena and noumenon, essence and marks can
be discussed ad infinitum .
However, if we can understand it, we understand everything. I sincerely hope
that fellow cultivators will skillfully reflect on this question to avoid being
misled while treading the Way.
When
the author had reached this point in the manuscript, a visiting lay Buddhist
asked, "I have heard a number of fairly accomplished Zen Masters say, 'The
intelligent should just concentrate their minds and have pure thoughts, without
wasting their time and effort to follow the illusion of Buddha Recitation. Let
us leave the vehicle empty so that it can run light, not weigh it down with
excess baggage!' I have heard such reasoning but do not know how to reply. I
wish you could elucidate the matter."
Answer: The aim of Zen is True
Thusness Samadhi. The goal of Pure Land is the Buddha Recitation Samadhi. True
Thusness Samadhi is like gold bullion, while Buddha Recitation Samadhi is
similar to gold necklaces, bracelets, and other pieces of jewelry. All contain
the basic metal gold. Therefore, when we have attained Buddha Recitation
Samadhi, we have attained True Thusness Samadhi as well. True Thusness Samadhi
centers on wisdom; Buddha Recitation Samadhi encompasses not only wisdom but
merit and virtue as well. This is because the Pure Land practitioner not only
bases himself on pure one-pointedness of mind, he receives the virtues derived
from reciting the Buddha's name in addition. However, neither True Thusness
Samadhi nor Buddha Recitation Samadhi can be attained in one lifetime; they are
the results of many eons of continuous practice. This is particularly true in
this Dharma-Ending Age.
Thus,
while Buddha Recitation Samadhi is the aim of the Pure Land method, it is not
the primary one. The principal and essential goal is to achieve rebirth in the
Pure Land within one lifetime so as to reach the stage of
non-retrogression. This is
what sets Pure Land apart from other schools and gives it its name.
This
is precisely why many Zen Masters, having awakened to the Way but realizing
that Supreme Enlightenment is still far away, change direction and adopt Buddha
Recitation seeking rebirth in the Pure Land. Although painstaking, reciting the
Buddha's name and bowing to images of the Buddhas bring additional merits and
virtues, a result of the cultivation of the two karmas of body and speech.
Take
the example of a truck returning to the capital from the mountain town
of ĐÀ LẠT. If, after discharging its cargo, the truck returns empty,
it will, of course, be lighter. However, if it can load up with vegetables and
other produce, the truck will not only be back in the capital, its owners will,
in addition, have a cargo of produce. Earning additional merits and blessings
through the diligent and painstaking efforts of Buddha Recitation is a natural
cause and effect occurrence -- where is the loss? However, any hardship, if it
does occur, will only be felt in the beginning stages of Buddha Recitation.
When
recitation has become second nature, reaching the level of No-Mind, all
hardship will have vanished!
One-Pointedness
of Mind -- Theory and Practice
The
practitioner of Buddha Recitation should strive earnestly to achieve a dual
goal. Intemally, he
should eliminate all marks of right and wrong, mine and yours, becoming
oblivious to body and mind. Extemally, he
should completely sever the marks of Emptiness, form and the Six Dusts, to the
point where he no longer grasps at external realms -- only the sacred name of
Amitabha Buddha remains before him.
This
utmost exertion of effort was best described by the ancients with the following
image:
In
front of him are ferocious tigers, behind a pack of wolves, on the left a high
mountainside, on the right a deep precipice. In such a situation, in which
direction should the practitioner escape?
The
Pure Land School expresses the same idea with the words:
The
seven jeweled lotus pond is in front of him, the cauldron of boiling oil above
the fire pit is behind him; the Buddha Recitation practitioner should
proceed straight ahead.
If
the practitioner does not see any sign of progress, it is because he himself
lacks strong will and is lazy. In this connection, an Elder Master once sternly
admonished the assembly:
The
way people today seek the Dharma is cause for lamentation,
Still outside the door, they are puzzled in so many ways!
Thinking they have reached the Sage-Emperor's jade city,
They have in fact stopped mid-way, at the mountain pass!
If
the practitioner exerts the utmost effort without interruption, he will, in
time, arrive at the realm of one-pointedness of mind. This sphere of undivided
attentiveness has two levels, superficial and subtle, called the level of
phenomena and the level of noumenon.
What is one-pointedness of mind at the level of phenomena?
When
the practitioner gives undivided attention to the sacred name of Amitabha
Buddha, all sundry thoughts are, in time, eliminated. Whether he is reclining
or sitting, walking or standing, only the sacred name appears before him. At
that point, he has reached the realm of one-pointedness of mind at the level of
phenomena. This is the concentration realm of the Pure Land
practitioner, equivalent to the level of "phenomena-concentration" in
Zen.
What is one-pointedness of mind at the noumenon level?
If
we go a step beyond the level of phenomena and exert our utmost efforts, one
day our mind will be completely empty, we will completely escape the dust of
the senses and become awakened to the True Mark. At that time, the present
moment is the Western Pure Land -- and this does not contradict the specific
existence of the Land of Ultimate Bliss; our nature is Amitabha Buddha -- and
this does not contradict the specific existence of the Lord Amitabha Buddha.
This is the realm of "one-pointedness of mind, noumenon level," the
realm of "concentration-wisdom being one and thus" of the Pure Land
practitioner.
This
stage is equivalent to the level of Great Awakening in Zen.
Elder
Master Ou-I elucidated the question of one-pointedness of mind in the following
way:
Regardless
of whether we practice recitation at the noumenon or phenomena level, if we
recite to the point where afflictions are subdued and Delusions of Views and
Delusions of Thought no longer arise, this is the realm of one-pointedness of
mind at the level of phenomena. Regardless of whether we practice at the
noumenon or phenomena level, if we recite to the point where the mind is
awakened and we clearly see the original Buddha Nature, this is the realm of
one-pointedness of mind at the noumenon level.
At
the level of phenomena, we are no longer
disturbed by delusions of view and delusions of thought; at the
noumenon level we are no longer disturbed by dualities (that is,
existence/non-existence, extinction/permanence, ...)
Thus,
one-pointedness of mind is not an easy thing for people today to achieve, even
at the level of phenomena, let alone at the level of noumenon. However, thanks
to the virtues obtained through recitation and earnest practice, each utterance
erases one part of delusion and engenders one part of merit and wisdom,
gradually and naturally leading us to rebirth in an auspicious realm. If we
practice in that manner over a long period of time, why worry about not
reaching the stage where each thought awakens and enlightens, leading to
auspicious realms?
This
idea is expressed in the phrase "each time a new thought arises, a new
realm appears."
Therefore,
even though we possess only the limited capacities of sentient beings in the
Dharma-Ending Age, if we truly exert ourselves, one-pointedness of mind, both
at the phenomena and noumenon levels, is not necessarily beyond our reach.
Internal
Realms
If
we are not diligent and do not exert efforts along the path of cultivation,
nothing usually happens; however, if we are diligent and exert a great deal of
effort, we will definitely witness different realms. They either come from
within the mind or are caused by outside sources. I will speak first about the
realms originating from the mind, called internal realms.
Internal
realms are also called "realms of the Self-Mind" because
they do not come from outside, but develop from the mind. Those who do not
clearly understand the truth that "the ten thousand dharmas are created by
the mind," think that all realms come from the outside. This is wrong.
When the practitioner reaches the stage of mind and realms, completely severing
external conditions, the seeds of latent dharmas in the Alaya consciousness
suddenly manifest themselves. For the Buddha Recitation or mantra-chanting
practitioner, the power of the Buddha's name or the mantra penetrates deep into
the mind, eliciting a reaction from the wholesome or evil seeds in the Alaya
consciousness. The realms that result are very complex and usually appear in
dreams, or even when the practitioner is awake and striving to recite the
Buddha's name. In Buddhism, this condition is called "changing
manifestations of the Alaya consciousness.
Dreaming scenes
If
the events or scenes result from evil seeds, the practitioner, in his dreams,
may see various species of worms crawling out of his body, or witness himself,
night after night, removing from his body six or seven loathesome creatures
with many limbs, such as scorpions or centipedes. Or else, he may see various
species of wild animals and/or spirits or ghosts. Such realms are innumerable
and cannot all be described!
In
general, individuals greatly afflicted with greed, who are miserly and wicked,
usually see marks of men and women, snakes and serpents and odd species
with white features and forms. Those harboring a great deal of anger and
resentment usually see tigers and leopards or strange species with red forms
and features. Those who are heavily deluded usually see domestic animals,
clams, oysters, snails or different species with black forms and features.
The
above, however, is merely indicative; it does not mean that everything will be
exactly as described.
If
the scenes in his dreams come from good, wholesome seeds, the practitioner sees
tall trees and exotic flowers, beautiful scenery, brightly adorned with nets of
pearls. Or else, he sees himself eating succulent, fragrant food, wearing
ethereal garments, dwelling in palaces of diamonds and other precious
substances, or flying high in open space.
Thus,
in summary, all the seeds of the ten Dharma Realms are found in the minds of
sentient beings. If wholesome seeds manifest themselves, practitioners view the
realms of Buddhas, Bodhisattvas, human and celestial beings; if evil karma is
manifested, they witness scenes from the wretched three Evil Paths. If the
cultivator has followed externalist ways in lives past, he usually sees his
body emitting electric waves, or his soul leaving the body to roam, meeting
demons, ghosts and the like, to discuss politics and the rise and fall of
countries and empires. On the other hand, when the practitioner's mind is
pure, he will know in his dreams about events that will occur three or four
days, or seven or eight months, hence. In general, those who have cultivated in
previous lives will immediately see auspicious realms when reciting the
Buddha's name.
Those
with heavy karma, lacking merit and virtue, will usually see evil realms when
they begin Buddha Recitation. In time, these evil omens will disappear and
gradually be replaced with auspicious omens.
Waking scenes
If
the practitioner's efforts have reached a high enough level, there are times
during his waking hours when all deluded feelings suddenly cease for a while,
body and mind being at ease and free. At other times, the practitioner may
recite for four or five hours but feel that the time was very short, perhaps
two or three minutes. Or else, at times during recitation, wholesome omens will
appear. At other times, unconsciously, his mind experiences great contentment
and bliss. Sometimes, he realizes for a split second that mind and realm are
both empty. At other times, just by hearing or seeing something once, he
becomes awakened to the truth of suffering, emptiness, impermanence and
No-Self, completely severing the marks of self and others. These occurrences are
too numerous to be fully described!
A
layman was once reciting the Buddha's name while seated in the dark. Suddenly,
he saw two types of flowers, red ones and white ones, springing up all over the
floor, reaching as high as the edge of his bed; meanwhile, other flowers were
dropping like rain from the sky. Another layman, while kneeling down to recite
the Buddha's name, suddenly saw a red lotus flower appear before the altar, its
bud gradually opening up and disappearing after a few minutes.
There
was yet another layman who, during recitation, would suddenly see everything
around him disappear. In front of his eyes would appear the scene of an immense
ocean, calm and still, with no wind or waves whatsoever; countless huge,
multicolored lotus blossoms would spring up on the ocean surface. Afterward,
the ocean scene would disappear, to be replaced by scenes of mountains, with
verdant herbs and flowers, luxuriant century-old trees, and, by and by, a
temple complex, sumptuous and magnificent. Then the temple and mountains would
disappear, to be replaced by scenes of jewelled nets coming together then
drawing apart, drawing apart then coming together again.
There
are, in general, many such scenes, which the author has heard
fellow-cultivators describe and which he has recounted here as examples.
Visionary
scenes such as the above, called "internal realms" or "realms of
the Self-Mind," have their origin in a thought of peace and stillness, or
are caused by wholesome seeds generated by Buddha or Mantra Recitation. They
appear suddenly and are lost immediately. The practitioner should not be
attached to them, thinking that they are real, nor should he remember them
fondly. It is a very great mistake to develop nostalgia for them, thinking how
ethereal, calm and peaceful, beautiful and well-adorned they were, then
day-dream about them, unable to forget them, longing for their reappearance.
The ancients have criticized such thoughts as "scratching in advance and
waiting for the itch." This is because these scenes have their origin in
diligent exertion and appear temporarily. They have no true existence. We
should realize that when the practitioner exerts a certain level of effort, the
scenes and features particular to that level will appear naturally.
Take
the example of a traveller who views different scenery as he passes along
various stretches of the road. If he has not reached home, yet develops such an
attachment and fondness for a particular scene along the road that he refuses
to proceed, his travel will be impeded. He will then be helplessly lost in the
midst of his journey, not knowing when he will finally return home to
rest. The practitioner is like that traveller; if he becomes attached
to and fond of temporary realms and scenes he will never attain the true realms.
Were he to dream of them to the point of insanity, he would be destroyed by
demons and waste an entire lifetime of practice!
The Diamond Sutra states:
Everything
in this world that has marks is illusory; to see marks as not marks is to see
the Tathagata.
"Everything
that has marks" refers here to compounded, conditioned dharmas. Those
marks cannot be said either to exist or not to exist, or to be true or false.
Delusions arise precisely because unenlightened sentient beings discriminate,
become attached and think that these marks exist or do not exist, are real or
are false. Even the fondness which some Zen practitioners develop for samadhi
(upon entering concentration and experiencing this immense, empty, still,
transparent, peaceful and free realm) falls into the category of "having
marks." The same is true when these practitioners, once awakened to a
certain lofty, transcendental principle, joyfully grasp at it. Once there are
marks, there is delusion.
"To
see marks" means to see such marks as auspicious/evil, good/bad,
dirty/clean, existent/ non-existent, Buddha/sentient beings, even the realms of
the Five Skandas or the Six Dusts, etc.
"As
not marks" means seeing but neither becoming attached to nor
rejecting them -- just letting everything be. Why should we not reject them? It
is because marks, while illusory, are not non-existent.
This is not unlike the reflection of the moon in the water. Although the
reflected moon is not real, this does not mean that there is no illusory mark
of moonlight. Therefore, if we see marks appear while we are cultivating, we
should disregard them and redouble our efforts, just like the traveller, who
views varied scenery en route but must push forward to reach home quickly.
"To
see the Tathagata" is to see the original Buddha
Nature, to see the Way.
In
summary, all states of mind, from those described above to the state of
one-pointedness of mind, belong to the category of "internal realms."
These realms have two aspects: "attainment-like" and "partial
attainment." "Attainment-like" realms appear temporarily and
disappear immediately. "Partial attainment" realms are those that
once achieved, we have forever, because we have actually attained a part of
True Thusness. Regardless of whether it is internal or external, if it is
"attainment-like" it is not a True Realm; it is merely a full
understanding of some of the manifestations of the True Mind.
Practitioners
who truly seek liberation should not confuse these aspects, taking
attainment-like marks for the True Realm. Attainment-like marks are like a
dark, leaden sky which suddenly clears, thanks to the winds which temporarily
push away the dark clouds, letting a few rays of sunlight through before the
sky becomes overcast again. They also resemble the "mark" of smoke
just before the fire, that people used to get when they rubbed two pieces of
wood together.
The
True Realm can be likened to the bright sunlight in a clear and calm sky. It is
like rubbing pieces of wood together and already having fire. However, we
should not underestimate attainment-like marks, as they demonstrate the genuine
existence of the True Realm. If, from that level, we diligently redouble our
efforts, the True Realm is not that far away after all.
External Realms
External realms are realms which are not created by the mind,
but come from the outside. For example, some practitioners might see Buddhas
and Bodhisattvas appearing before them, preaching the Dharma, exhorting and
praising them. Others, while reciting the Buddha's name, suddenly experience an
awakening and immediately see the Land of Ultimate Bliss. Some practitioners,
in the midst of their pure recitation, see deities and Immortals arrive, join
hands and circumambulate them respectfully, or invite them for a leisurely
stroll. Still other practitioners see "wandering souls of the dead"
arrive, seeking to "take refuge" with them. Yet others, having
reached a high level in their practice, have to endure challenges and
harassment from external demons.
For example, there was once a layman of rather dull capacities
who constantly worshipped the Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara. During a dream one
night, he saw the Bodhisattva urging him to meditate on the following stanza,
and in time he would experience a Great Awakening:
Great wisdom develops from the Mind,
Where in the Mind can it be found?
To realize all meanings,
Is to have neither past nor present.
Another story concerns a nun of the author's acquaintance who
was cultivating in the vicinity of Dalat. After her Buddha Recitation session,
as she was seated in meditation, she saw two men of noble countenance, dressed
like deities or Immortals, respectfully inviting her to scale the mountains and
visit their beautiful grounds. In her samadhi, she asked them, "How can I
go, when the mountains are so high and I am so weak?" One of the men said,
"Do not worry, I have a way." He then touched her lightly with something
similar to a willow branch and requested her to follow him. She suddenly saw
her body glide effortlessly over the grass, and, in no time, she was scaling
the mountains. There she witnessed ethereal scenes, with gigantic trees and a
palace and tower in the distance. At that very moment, a companion in the back
room dropped something with a bang. The nun suddenly awakened from
meditation. All scenes had disappeared but her thighs were still aching
from overexertion.
The realms and manifestations summarized above are called
"external realms." Some might ask, "To see Buddhas and lotus
blossoms -- is it not to see demonic apparitions?"
Answer: If cause and effect coincide, these are not
"demonic realms." This is because the Pure Land method
belongs to the Dharma Door of Existence; when Pure Land practitioners first set
out to cultivate, they enter the Way through forms and marks and seek to view
the celestial scenes of the Western Pure Land. When they actually witness these
auspicious scenes, it is only a matter of effects corresponding to causes. If
cause and effect are in accord, how can these be "demonic realms"?
In the Zen School, on the other hand, the practitioner enters
the Way through the Dharma Door of Emptiness. Right from the beginning of his
cultivation he wipes out all marks -- even the marks of the Buddhas or the
Dharma are destroyed. The Zen practitioner does not seek to view the Buddhas or
the lotus blossoms, yet the marks of the Buddhas or the lotus blossoms appear
to him. Therefore, cause and effect do not correspond. For something to appear
without a corresponding cause is indeed the realm of the demons. Thus, the Zen
practitioner always holds the sword of wisdom aloft. If the demons come, he
kills the demons, if the Buddha comes, he kills the Buddha -- to enter
the realm of True Emptiness is not to tolerate a single mark.
A caveat: we are only talking here about novice
cultivators. High-level Zen practitioners do sometimes see various
marks which are not demonic realms. When their minds become
enlightened, Zen Masters who have practiced meditation for many eons can see
evil as well as transcendental realms, including the pure and defiled lands of
the ten directions. This is because all worlds are within the light of the True
Mind. On the other hand, despite what we have said earlier, Buddha
Recitation practitioners sometimes see various marks which are "demonic
realms," as will be explained later.
In short, when we refer to "internal"
and "external" realms, we are speaking at the level of beginning
cultivators. For those who have attained the Way, Mind is realm, realm is Mind,
the ten thousand dharmas and ourselves have but one common Nature. There is no
inside or outside at all.
Discussion
on Demonic Realms
As
indicated above, sometimes the Buddha Recitation practitioner sees marks and
forms which could actually be demonic realms. These are instances where cause
and effect do not correspond. For example, while visualizing the physical
features of Amitabha Buddha, a practitioner may suddenly see the features of a
beautiful woman. Another cultivator, diligently reciting the Buddha's name in
the hope of seeing auspicious scenes of the Pure Land, may unexpectedly see a
slum area, with men, women and domestic animals running back and forth in all
directions. Yet another practitioner, hoping to see precious lotus blossoms in
the Pure Land, suddenly sees a small cart instead. These are demonic realms, as
cause and effect do not correspond.
There
are five criteria that can help us determine which events are real and which
belong to the demonic realms.
1. Instances
where cause and effect do not correspond (such as visualizing one mark
but seeing another, hoping to see one realm but seeing another), as well as
scenes and realms that do not resemble those described in the sutras, are all
demonic realms.
2.
Buddhas and Bodhisattvas have pure compassion; therefore, even if they take the
appearance of "demons" to test us, we still feel calm, at peace and
pure. Demons, on the contrary, are inherently evil and wicked; thus,
even when they take the appearance of Buddhas and Bodhisattvas, we feel
agitated, angry and uneasy.
3. The
Buddhas' light makes us feel calm and refreshed; it has neither shadow nor a
blinding effect on the eye. The light of demons, on the other hand,
affects our eyes and makes us feel agitated rather than calm and peaceful; it
also has shadows. The reference to the Buddhas' light in the Lankavatara Sutra illustrates this
point.
4. The
teachings of the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas are in accord with the sutras and the
truth. The words of demons are contrary to the truth and not in line
with the sutras' teachings.
5. When
an auspicious mark appears, the practitioner who wishes to test it need only
concentrate on reciting the Heart
Sutra with a pure mind, or reciting a mantra or the Buddha's name with
one-pointedness of mind. If the mark really is
auspicious, the more he recites, the clearer it becomes, because genuine gold
is not harmed by fire. If it belongs to the demonic realm, it disappears as he
recites, because evil can never withstand the truth.
We
should judge events by all five of the above criteria, not just one or two.
This
is because there are many celestial demons, externalist deities and Immortals
who want to lead us their way and therefore falsely take the appearance of
Buddhas and Bodhisattvas preaching the Dharma. Although their cultivation is
not the ultimate Way leading to liberation, they may have good karma or a
fairly high level of samadhi. Thus, their "light" can also make us
feel refreshed and peaceful. Moreover, their teachings at times also encourage
the performance of good deeds, keeping the precepts, vegetarianism and Buddha
Recitation. However, they diverge from the Buddhist sutras on certain
crucial points [such as the need to escape Birth and Death]. Only by exercising
careful judgement and understanding the Dharma in depth are we able to know.
For
example, certain externalist deities urge vegetarianism and Buddha Recitation,
but teach that the sacred words should be visualized as circulating throughout
the body -- this, they say, is "turning the Dharma
wheel," to release blockages in the energy system. This is the
preaching of externalist demons.
There
are also demons who take the appearance of Elder Masters and say, "Buddha
statues made of bronze or cement cannot vanquish water, because they sink in
water; Buddha statues made of wood or paper cannot vanquish fire, because they
would burn. Only the Mind-Buddha cannot be destroyed by anything. You need only
cultivate the Mind-Buddha, striving to make it pure; there is no need to
cultivate body and speech. Therefore, even 'eating meat and drinking wine, lusting
and begetting children' [in the case of monks and nuns] are of no consequence.
Cultivating body and speech through such restrictive, ascetic practices as
precept-keeping, vegetarianism, Sutra, Mantra and Buddha Recitation is of no
use and brings no benefit!" This is a typical teaching of some
spirits of long years' standing or demons of sexual lust.
There
are some types of demon who have reached a fairly high level of attainment and
can use their powers of concentration to help the practitioner reach a state of
samadhi for a period of seven or twenty-one days. However, their teaching does
not lead to ultimate liberation and, in the end, cannot transcend the cycle of
ego-attachment.
Ancient
masters have said:
When
we see demons yet remain undisturbed, the demons self-destruct; when we see
ghosts yet remain undisturbed, the ghosts are vanquished.
This
saying means: if we see demons and ghosts but our minds are unmoved and
unafraid, holding fast to correct thoughts or singlemindedly reciting the
Buddha's name, these demons and ghosts cannot hurt us in any way, and will
leave of their own accord.
Not
only should we act in such a manner when seeing demons, but even when we
achieve some results or see auspicious marks during cultivation, we should not
be moved to astonishment, sadness or joy. It is as if we had lost a diamond at
the bottom of the lake and because the water was murky, we were unable to
recover it despite our best efforts. However, once the water became still and
transparent, we found it. Since the diamond had always belonged to us, why
should we have been astonished and happy? If the cultivator's mind is not calm
and peaceful and is overly given to sorrowful compassion, he will be harmed by
the demon of sorrow and cry all the time. If he is given to too much happiness,
he will be harmed by the demon of happiness and laugh all the time, as though
insane.
Thus,
although the Pure Land practitioner may also hope to see transcendental realms
and scenes, he should not long for or dream of them too much, because to recite
is already to seek. He should be calm and "seek but not seek, not seek but
seek," so as to avoid disturbing his mind. He should just earnestly recite
the Buddha's name and in time, when the power of his recitation is pure, there
will be a response and he will witness auspicious realms. To
continuously seek and hope for them is deluded thought which brings harm.
Long
ago in China there was a layman who had engaged in meditation for some thirty
years. One day, he suddenly attained the faculty of transcendental vision. At
the beginning, he would see through walls; later on, he could see things within
a few dozen miles as clearly as though they were in front of his eyes.
Realizing that he had achieved "transcendental vision," he was very
astonished and happy! As time went on, he was not only able to "see"
but also "hear" the voices of human beings and animals from far away.
This is transcendental hearing, which develops after transcendental vision. As
time went by, he could see and hear things that occurred within a radius of
several thousand miles. Still later, he was able to predict future events.
Thus, he "knew" in advance of a war between two neighboring kingdoms
and "witnessed" the pitiful sight of countless dead and dying among
the populace. He was so moved that he would weep and lament to whomever he met,
"A great, violent uprising is going to occur. There will be massacres and
utter misery. The people deserve pity and compassion. How can they be helped!
At
the time, everyone who heard him thought he was insane. Later on, however, war
and rebellion did occur as he had predicted. Even when the disturbances were
over, he continued to go around lamenting. A respected master once commented:
This
is a case of possession by the "demons of sorrow and sadness." The
cultivator who has reached a certain high level of practice suddenly develops
"transcendental vision." He should reflect it toward the Self-Nature,
not letting worldly Dusts move and disturb his mind. He should realize that
these psychic powers have always been in his possession and should therefore
not be unduly happy or astonished or consider them strange and wonderful
occurrences.
Another
story concerns the eminent Chinese Zen Master Nan-Ch'uan:
The
master was meditating in a hut next to a river. One night he heard two ghosts
conversing. One of them was rejoicing that his term was coming to an end
because the next day someone would be replacing him. The second ghost asked,
"Who will be replacing you?" He replied, "A man wearing an iron
hat." The master wondered to himself who this person could be. The next
day there was heavy rain and the river rose to a higher level. The master
looked out of his hut and saw a man about to cross the river. He had covered
his head with a wok for protection against the rain. Immediately, the master
knew that this was the man of the iron hat, so he cautioned him saying,
"Don't cross the river today. It's too dangerous." The man asked,
"Why?" "Because the water is very deep and running
rapidly." The man listened to the old monk's advice and returned home.
You
must understand that in Chinese lore, water ghosts are prisoners until another
person drowns and takes their place. That night as he was meditating, the
master heard the two ghosts again. This time the first ghost was complaining,
"I have been stuck here for so many years, and I thought my chance for
freedom had finally come. But now the old monk interfered and messed everything
up. I'll show him what I can do."
Upon
hearing this exchange, the master immediately entered samadhi. He saw the
demons enter, exit and go around his hut, as if searching for someone. However,
thanks to the fact that his mind in samadhi was empty and still, "not
influenced by the environment, no longer tied to mental objects," the
demons could not see him. Discouraged, they finally left.
Of
the two stories in this section, the first illustrates the danger of succumbing
to the influence of demons while the second points to the way of overcoming
their influence. I have recounted them here for the benefit of
fellow-cultivators.
Various
Types of Demons
The
author had just finished drafting the previous three sections when he was
visited by a Dharma master who requested him to elaborate on the different
types of demons for the benefit of fellow-cultivators. In the three previous
sections he has, in fact, given a general explanation of the different realms, including
those of demons. If the cultivator has understood the main idea, he can keep
his mind undisturbed and counteract all harmful occurrences. However, to comply
with this request, the author will describe the different types of demons in
greater detail, as follows.
"Demons" are
called "mara" in Sanskrit. In Chinese, the word has the connotation
of "murderer" because demons usually plunder the virtues and murder
the wisdom-life of cultivators. "Demons" also represent the
destructive conditions or influences that cause practitioners to retrogress in
their cultivation. Demons can render cultivators insane, making them lose their
right thought, develop erroneous views, commit evil karma and end up sunk in
the lower realms.
Those
activities which develop virtue and wisdom and lead sentient beings to Nirvana
are called Buddha work. Those activities which destroy good roots, causing
sentient beings to suffer and revolve in the cycle of Birth and Death, are
called demonic actions. The longer a practitioner cultivates, and the higher his
level of attainment, the more he discovers how wicked, cunning and powerful the
demons are. Although there are numerous demons, they can be divided into three
types: demons of afflictions, external demons and celestial demons.
Demons of afflictions
These
demons represent the afflictions of greed, anger, resentment, delusion,
contempt, doubt and wrong views. They also include the demons of the Five
Skandas, the Six Entrances, the Twelve Sense Fields and the Eighteen Elements.
These demons are also called "internal" as they are created by
topsy-turvy, delusive states of mind. Therefore, they must be overcome by the
bright, enlightened mind.
The
human mind is easily moved, developing afflictions not only because of personal
karma but also because of the common karma of living in an environment filled
to a great extent with beings subject to evil karma. Some persons cannot resist
the attractions of the five Dusts and thus fall into evil ways. Others,
encountering adverse conditions, grow sad and mournful and lose their
determination to progress. Such developments, depending on their severity,
render the cultivator despondent, indignant and ill, or worse still, cause him
to abandon the Buddhist Order or even to commit suicide out of despair. More
harmful still, they can lead to loss of respect and good will toward other
cultivators, sometimes even hatred and avoidance of clergy and lay people
alike. Loss of faith in cause and effect, bad karma and finally, descent upon
the three Evil Paths are the end result.
To
counteract these demons, the practitioner should reflect that all afflictions
are illusory, upsetting, suffocating, binding, evil and conducive only to
suffering for both himself and others. To eliminate afflictions is to return to
the True Mind, free and liberated, fresh and tranquil, bright and clear, happy
and at peace, transcendental and wondrous. The cultivator should also meditate
in the same way on all attachments, from the Five Skandas to the Eighteen
Elements. In the Lotus
Sutra, Sakyamuni Buddha said:
You
should not be greedy and attached to gross and vile forms, sound, smell, taste,
touch and dharmas. If you do, they will burn you up.
The
Bodhisattva Manjusri once asked a female deity, "How do you see the
Eighteen Elements?" The deity replied, "They are similar to the conic
fire burning up the whole world." These are words of warning, reminding us
to eliminate the demons of afflictions.
If
the demons of afflictions (internal demons) are not subdued, they will attract
"external demons" which wreak havoc. The ancients have said:
If
behind the door there are mean-spirited people, mean-spirited people will
arrive at the door; if behind the door there are virtuous, superior people,
noble superior people will arrive at the door.
Furthermore,
when thieves try to enter a house through the side door, if the owner calmly
scolds them in a loud voice, they will naturally be frightened and leave. If,
on the other hand, he is terrified and panic-stricken, and begs them to desist,
he will unwittingly be inviting them into his house.
External demons
"External
demons" take the form of various spirits, ghosts and deities. Once the
cultivator has reached a certain level of attainment, he will be subject to
demonic disturbances which will put him to the test. External demons may be
divided into three groups.
1. Terrorizing Demons
These
are ghosts that like to frighten and terrorize people. They usually take the
form of tigers, wolves, deadly serpents, poisonous snakes or other ferocious
beasts or hallucinatory, diabolic apparitions to scare the cultivator. Their
forms change ad infinitum. They
may have no head or many heads, many hands, many eyes, or a half-human,
half-bestial body. They may brandish weapons or spit fire. If the practitioner
is frightened, he loses his right thought and often goes insane.
Faced
with these occurrences, we should reflect that all forms and marks are
illusory, and that demons can only destroy the illusory body, not the True
Mind. Meditating this way, we should remain calm and unafraid of death,
peacefully concentrating on Buddha or Mantra Recitation. The demons will then
retreat of their own accord.
2. Demons of Lust and Attachment
These
are a type of demon which excites a range of emotions, from lust to delusive
attachment to the realm of the five Dusts [i.e., this world]. They take the
appearance of alluring, nude men and women or of parents, siblings or close
relatives, as well as of Buddhas and Bodhisattvas with beautiful, adorned
features, in order to entice the practitioner. If he is fond of good food,
these demons bring him succulent, fragrant dishes. If he likes diamonds or
gold, they take the appearance of strange animals holding precious stones in
their mouths as offerings. They cause whatever the practitioner desires to
appear. They can also use their psychic power to lead him into evil samadhi,
evil wisdom and eloquence, giving him the mystic power to know the past and the
future.
Those
who do not understand will mistake these occurrences for evidence that the
practitioner has attained Enlightenment, and thus believe in and trust him. In
reality, however, the cultivator's mind is upside down and he spends all his
time engaging in errant, demonic practices to deceive others.
Once
there was a Vietnamese monk cultivating at a deserted temple in Laos. In one of
his meditation sessions, he saw a group of beautiful, ethereal women, all
naked, holding hands and dancing around. The monk, unable to calm his agitated
mind, immediately recited the Buddha's name in all earnestness. Only then did
this scene disappear.
Another story: Once, in China, there
was a monk seated in meditation. Because he was cold and hungry, the thought of
food arose in his mind. He suddenly saw a woman presenting him with an offering
of food. The woman knelt, put food in his bowl, and respectfully asked him to
eat immediately, before the food grew cold and lost all taste. The monk, being
hungry wanted to eat at once but remembering that it was not yet noon [the
prescribed mealtime for monks and nuns], he patiently told her to put the bowl
aside for the time being. The woman left, appearing angry and upset. Some time
later, at noon, he uncovered the bowl to discover that it was full of worms,
crawling all around. He then understood that his false thought of food had
attracted the demonic apparitions. Thanks to his power of concentration,
however limited, he avoided consuming the dirty food and violating the precept
against killing.
Yet
another story concerns a Zen monk who practiced in a deserted mountain area.
Lonely and isolated, he had a deluded thought, wishing to have some fellow-cultivators
practicing along with him to make life more bearable. Immediately, an old woman
appeared from nowhere, leading two beautiful young girls by the hand, who, she
said, lived in the village down in the valley. They had come, they claimed, to
seek guidance in the Way. The monk, unsuspicious, immediately gave a Dharma
talk to the group. One day, after many such visits over a period of time, the
old woman respectfully requested that the two girls be allowed to become
attendants to the monk and relieve him of his daily chores. The monk, hearing
this, became suspicious. He reprimanded the old woman severely and refused the
offer. The three women left, apparently angry and ashamed.
The
monk, intrigued, followed them discreetly until they disappeared around a bend
in the road. When he reached the spot, he found it was a dead end with no
habitation or anything else around, except for three very old trees, one big
tree and two smaller ones. He thought it over and realized that he had been
"tested." A fleeting thought occurred to him, that he should cut down
the trees, start a bonfire, and burn them to the ground. At that moment, the
three women reappeared, repentant, begging him to forgive them and spare their
lives.
Therefore,
the cultivator should remember: when the mind is still, all realms are calm;
when delusion arises, demons are born.
3. Nuisance Demons
This
type of demon concentrates on harassing and disturbing the practitioner. There
is a certain species of spirits and ghosts which can be subdivided into many
types, each appearing at a fixed time of the day. In general, each hour has
three types of spirits ... For example, during the period between seven and
nine in the morning, they take the appearance of dragons, fish and serpent-like
creatures.
In
his commentary Samatha and Vipasyana for Beginners, the
Patriarch Chih-I mentioned a type of demon with a face like a pear-shaped lute,
four eyes and two mouths, which enjoys disturbing cultivators. Waiting for the
individual to begin practice, it takes the form of worms or tiny insects and
crawls all over his head and face, penetrates into his mouth, nose, eyes and
ears, or goes under his armpits or belly to sting him. At other times it shouts
loudly into the practitioner's ears, creating a great disturbance and giving
him a headache; or it suddenly embraces him tightly. If the practitioner
attempts to seize it in return, nothing is there. This type of nuisance demon
also causes scenes of the five Dusts to appear, either favorable or
unfavorable, or neither favorable nor unfavorable. Such transformations are
countless and can cause the practitioner to become agitated. As he does not
know what to make of all this, he loses his concentration. The general way to
subdue these nuisance demons is to "gather" the mind in correct
samadhi, or diligently recite mantras or the Buddha's name -- they will then
all disappear.
Speaking
more broadly, the category of "external demons" also includes demons
belonging to externalist cults and other false or quasi-Buddhist sects.
According to the observations of this author and many of his colleagues,
practitioners who have belonged to cults in this or previous lives but have now
converted to Buddhism, as well as those who are themselves Buddhists but who
come from families formerly active in other faiths and cults, tend to be
bothered by external demons. This is because the cultivation methods of
externalists are within the realm of worldly afflictions and are tainted with
pride, ego attachment, power and fame. Therefore, they stick together and do
not want people connected with them in some way to follow other teachings.
A
case in point is a friend of the author, a Buddhist monk of gentle and peaceful
disposition, who was continuously disturbed by externalist demons during his
cultivation. Unfortunately, because of his "externalist" past seeds,
he did not apply the Dharma wholeheartedly, but went instead from place to
place, seeking help from externalists. In the end, he strayed completely from
Buddhism. While taking the outside appearance of a Buddhist monk, he spent all
his time "balancing energy currents" while denigrating such practices
as bowing to the Buddhas and reciting sutras as attachments to forms. Thus,
those who were once affiliated with externalist faiths and later returned to
the Dharma, should reflect on this example and be cautious.
Celestial Demons
This
refers to the type of demon that resides in the Sixth Heaven, also called the
Heaven of Free Enjoyment of Others' Emanations. This type of demon possesses
merits and blessings and enjoys the highest heavenly bliss in the Realm of
Desire [of which our world is but a small part]. They then mistake such
happiness and bliss as ultimate, and do not wish anyone to escape their
influence.
When
a practitioner has attained a fairly high level of cultivation, his mind-light
develops and shines up to the realm of the Sixth Heaven. It is then discovered
by the celestial demons, who seek ways to sabotage his cultivation. Such action
can take many forms, threatening or cajoling, or even helping the practitioner
attain false samadhi, "wisdom" and spiritual power, with the aim of
ultimately deceiving him. These demons take turns watching the practitioner
constantly and without interruption, waiting for the opportune moment. If the
practitioner has a delusive thought, they pounce on him or steer him toward
things contrary to the Way. The practitioner's entire lifetime of cultivation
is then over, for all practical purposes.
In
his Awakening of the Faith Treatise,
the Patriarch Asvaghosha admonished:
There
may be some disciples whose root of merit is not yet mature, whose control of
mind is weak and whose power of application is limited -- and yet who are
sincere in their purpose to seek enlightenment -- these for a time may be beset
and bewildered by maras and evil influences who are seeking to break down their
good purpose.
Such
disciples, seeing seductive sights, attractive girls, strong young men, must
constantly remind themselves that all such tempting and alluring things are
mind-made, and, if they do this, their tempting power will disappear and they
will no longer be annoyed. Or, if they have visions of heavenly gods and
Bodhisattvas and Buddhas surrounded by celestial glories, they should remind
themselves that these, too, are mind-made and unreal. Or, if they should be
uplifted and excited by listening to mysterious Dharanis, to lectures upon the
paramitas, to elucidations of the great principles of the Mahayana, they must
remind themselves that these also are emptiness and mind-made, that in their
essence they are Nirvana itself. Or, if they should have intimations within
that they have attained transcendental powers, recalling past lives, or
fore-seeing future lives, or, reading others' thoughts, or freedom to visit
other Buddha-lands, or great powers of eloquence, all of [these] may tempt them
to become covetous for worldly power and riches and fame. Or, they may be
tempted by extremes of emotion, at times angry, at other times joyous, or at
times very kind-hearted and compassionate, at other times the very opposite, or
at times alert and purposeful, at other times indolent and stupid, at times
full of faith and zealous in their practice, at other times engrossed in other
affairs and negligent.
All
of will keep them vacillating, at times experiencing a kind of fictitious
samadhi, such as the heretics boast of, but not the true samadhi. Or later,
when they are quite advanced become absorbed in trances for a day, or two, or
even seven, not partaking of any food but upheld by inward food of their
spirit, being admired by their friends and feeling very comfortable and proud
and complacent, and then later becoming very erratic, sometimes eating little,
sometimes greedily, and the expression of their face constantly changing.
Because
of all such strange manifestations and developments in the course of their
practices, disciples should be on their guard to keep the mind under constant
control. They should neither grasp after nor become attached to the passing and
unsubstantial things of the senses or concepts and moods of the mind. If they
do this they will be able to keep far away from the hindrances of karma.
In
summary and as a further generalization, there are only two types of demon,
internal and external. Celestial demons are within the category of external
demons; however, I have described them separately to alert the practitioner to
the dangerous, subtle havoc they can cause. In addition to the demons of
afflictions, external demons and celestial demons described above, Buddhist
sutras also mention "disease demons" and the "demon of
death." A bout of disease will usually wither the practitioner's efforts,
while death in the midst of cultivation can make him retrogress. Thus, disease
and death are called demons. In general, they represent obstacles to the Way
that affect the physical body, but they cannot harm and destroy the Bodhi Mind
in the true sense of the word "demon." For this reason, they are only
mentioned in passing, but not elaborated upon here.
Considering
the level of cultivation of today's practitioners, they generally face
harassment only from demons of afflictions or external demons. Such cultivators
are not advanced enough to arouse opposition from celestial demons. However,
should the latter set their minds to destroying someone, that person has little
hope of escaping harm, unless his cultivation is exemplary.
In
the Surangama Sutra,
Buddha Sakyamuni, out of compassion for cultivators faced with many dangers
along the Way, advised those who practiced meditation to recite mantras at the
same time. This would enable them to rely on the power of the Buddhas to escape
harm from demons and achieve correct samadhi.
The
Patriarch Yin Kuang once said:
At
first glance, it would appear that the Surangama Sutra has a different
viewpoint from Pure Land. However, upon closer scrutiny, that Sutra, in its
essence, actually praised and commended the Pure Land School. Why is this so?
It is because, if even those who have attained the third level of sagehood can
suffer retrogression caused by demons, we can see the crucial importance of
Buddha Recitation and rebirth in the Pure Land: in the "gathering"
and helping light of the Lord Amitabha Buddha, there is no more
danger of demons.
While
treading the Way but not yet reborn in the Pure Land, the practitioner of
Buddha Recitation may also encounter demonic obstacles. However, in most cases,
this is because he does not understand the Dharma and is not skillful at
reining in his mind -- letting internal demons spring up, which, in turn,
attract external demons. If he can keep his mind empty and still and recite the
Buddha's name, external demons will be powerless and afflictions will gradually
disappear. Thus, for the Pure Land practitioner, even if demonic obstacles do
appear, they are few in number.
Zen
practitioners, on the other hand, face many demonic occurrences because they
rely only on their own strength and self-power. A Zen follower should fulfill
the following five conditions to be successful: first, he should keep the
precepts strictly; secondly, his nature and roots should be "quick"
and enlightened; thirdly, he should have a clear understanding of the Dharma,
skillfully distinguishing the correct from the deviant, the true from the
false; fourthly, he should be firm and stable in his determination; and
fifthly, he should be guided by a good advisor, who has a thorough
understanding of the sutras and many years experience in meditation. If the
practitioner does not meet these five conditions, he is very easily subject to
harm from demons.
The
ancients have said that "in Zen practice, there are many opportunities to
go astray." Therefore, to be successful in meditation, it is necessary to
possess superior capacities and intelligence. High-level Zen Masters of the
past, in transmitting the Dharma to their disciples, would repeatedly warn them:
Be
careful not to accept as a disciple anyone who does not have the deepest good
roots and the highest capacities.
These
words should serve as proof enough of the above observation.
In
the Awakening of the Faith Treatise after
summarizing the essential points of Mahayana doctrine and explaining the path
of cultivation, the Patriarch Asvaghosha added:
Next,
suppose there is a man who learns this teaching for the first time and wishes
to seek the correct faith but lacks courage and strength. Because he lives in
this world of suffering, he fears that he will not always be able to meet the
Buddhas and honor them personally, and that faith being difficult to perfect,
he will be inclined to fall back.
He
should know that the Tathagathas have an excellent expedient means by which
they can protect his faith: that is, through the strength of wholehearted
meditation-recitation on the Buddha [Amitabha], he will in fulfillment of his
wishes be able to be born in the Buddha-land beyond, to see the Buddha always,
and to be forever separated from the evil states of existence.
It
is as the sutra says: "If a man meditates wholly on Amitabha Buddha in the
world of the Western Paradise and wishes to be born in that world, directing
all the goodness he has cultivated toward that goal, then he will be born
there." Because he will see the Buddha at all times, he will never fall
back ..., he will be able to be born there in the end because he abides in the
correct samadhi.
As
explained above, diligent Buddha Recitation is a wonderful expedient to escape
demonic dangers and swiftly attain correct samadhi.
Comments
Post a Comment